Share article Ana's story: the bright side and the seamy side: Hi guys, today we worked a little bit more on Ana's story and you had ...
Hi guys,
today we worked a little bit more on Ana's story and you had to determine whether it was a positive or a negative experience for her to have gone to the US.
Here is the chart that we drew about the two sides of her adventure and our conclusion:
- indeed Ana feels uprooted. Even if she is the breadwinner of the family and it makes her happy, she is not with her children.
She fled Mexico because she and her family used to live below the poverty line. She went to the US in order to achieve her dreams and improve her family's life.
- At the beginning, when she arrived, she was still destitute and cut off from society. It must have been difficult to adapt, above all because she was an unskilled worker. She may also have felt rejected.
VOCAB:
a seam
root -> uprooted
flee (fled-fled)
determined to succeed
Seamy side Bright Side
|
LONELINESS: · Although they were poor there were content, now the family is torn apart. · Ana hasn’t seen her infant son since he was 1. · Ana can’t see her siblings. · She earns little money according to American standards.
· Angel (daughter) has no friends -> the neighbours are
jealous and they fear they might steal from the family. · Ana can’t live with her family. · Ana’s children don’t consider her as their mother but only the breadwinner who sends gifts. · Ana's mother suffers without her children.
ALIENATION: · Ana has been sucked into consumerism. · Ana's mother thinks she has forgotten where she used to live / where comes from. THE LIFE OF AN ILLEGAL ALIEN: · Ana is an outlaw |
SUCCESS: · Better life. ALTRUISM: · She helps her family to have what they want.
· Expensive house (in Mexico) · Ana and her siblings helped build the house
· Ana's family has lots of money consdering Mexican
standards. INTEGRATION/ASSIMILATION: · American friends. · Cristina offered a job which allowed her to have an apartment. · She admits she as a new taste of the “good life”. · Ana has been sucked into consumerism. |
All the parts of the bright side of her adventure hide
a seamy side. It’s two sides of the same coin. But there are 2 points of view. Ana’s point of view: she is satisfied /
content with her new life and well-integrated.
Her family’s POV (her mother's): they wish the family could be united again.
HW:
- d'ici à jeudi: aller voir l'exposition au CDI et trouver des questions à poser (au moins 5) concernant les oeuvres exposées. Vous devez vous montrer curieux et préparer votre conférence sur le thème.
- pour mercredi: traduction d'un passage du texte de: "But back..." jusqu'à "... food".
- pour mercredi: être capable de faire un compte rendu oral sur le texte en incluant les remarques faites aujourd'hui, en les expliquant et en les développant.
- Actualisez vos fiches de vocabulaire... Test de vocabulaire très prochainement...
Latest Comments